Staunch advocates of a revitalised manufacturing sector often quote Australia’s low ranking in Harvard’s Economic Complexity Index, and weak business R&D expenditure (BRDE) as a percentage of GDP as reasons for more Government investment to build manufacturing capability. They compare Australia to Germany and everyone else, yet it is not clear that Australia’s BRDE is falling behind. As a general proposition, evidence consistently indicates that investment in R&D increases firms’ future profitability, has a positive impact on a firm’s market value and earns excess shareholder returns. However, at a firm level this relationship is more nuanced.

Businesses that compete, or have to compete, by differentiating their products and services to gain a competitive advantage in the market (eg. technology driven products)secure excess returns to investment in R&D, but the level of return differs by industry. Hi-tech and medtech industries secure the highest returns but at higher risk premium – commercialisation is higher risk and technology change is rapid. Engineering firms must invest in R&D to stay competitive, but excess returns on investment are muted. In both instances, developing competitive advantage and translating it into firm outperformance how well ore dependent on how well R&D investment aligns to business strategy. This depends on a range of internal intangibles that are hard to value but difficult to copy. These include executive sponsorship, management focus, skills and knowledge, resource allocation and functional alignment between R&D, finance, manufacturing, marketing and sales. These intangibles make the R&D process efficient and create confidence in organisational ability to continue to invest in products and services that meet market needs and succeed financially.

Firms that compete on cost efficiency, and invest in R&D to drive operational efficiency also secure strong returns on R&D. However, a cost leadership strategy is focused on cost control. R&D spending and product innovation are not core competitive advantages, are often tightly controlled to minimize cost and standardise products to maximise economises of sale and margins. Overspending on R&D doesn’t make sense.

For each business, depending on their sector, market position and business strategy, there is an optimal level of R&D beyond which further investment delivers lower returns. The optimum level of R&D spending is therefore hard to aggregate and compare at an economy-wide level. It all depends.

There are several clear insights for businesses and policy-makers:

1. The efficiency of business R&D processes – measured by how many $R&D is needed to generate $1 of additional revenue / gross margin – is important regardless of the business strategy pursued.
2. It is better to showcase in detail Australian businesses that are growing quickly internationally on the back of on-going investment in R&D, so that other businesses can follow their pathway in their industries, than to decry our low ranking in someone else’s scorecard. What these business are doing and how they have secured government assistance along the way is the only thing that matters.
3. Businesses with revenue >$20M probably should not be penalised under the Government’s R&D Tax Incentive Program if their level of R&D Intensity is low. They may well be competing on cost effectiveness and optimising the level of R&D investment that is right for them.
4. Grant programs that prioritise “innovation” presume that growth businesses compete on product differentiation. These programs would be more effective if they focused on scale-up (or economies of scale through digitisation/automation etc) as an alternative category. Success criteria might reduce the focus on increased employment and diversity of employment, and focus instead on revenue, margin growth, and sustainability.

The easiest way to grow our manufacturing capability is to grow our start-ups and SME’s into bigger self-sustaining enterprises regardless of the industry they are in. This will build sovereign capability, accelerate digitisation and automation of our manufacturing base. Even as we continue to ride the back of an endless commodity bounty.

Share This